Evolutionary Ecology

In many tropical areas, seasonal rainfall leads to distinct dry and wet seasons. Many butterflies developing under wet season conditions develop into adults with large ventral eyespots on the wing margins, whereas those developing under dry season conditions have smaller or no eyespots. In greener, wet season habitats, larger eyespots can divert predator attacks toward the wing margins, while reduced eyespot size improves camouflage in the dry leaf litter-dominated habitat during the dry season. However, the dry season is also characterised by higher desiccation stress than the wet season. We hypothesised that larvae developing under dry season conditions develop into adults with higher desiccation tolerance than those reared under wet season conditions. We tested this by rearing larvae of the butterfly Mycalesis mineus under simulated dry and wet season conditions and assaying the desiccation tolerance of the resulting adults. Butterflies reared in dry conditions survived longer under desiccation stress, lost lesser water during pupal-adult metamorphosis, and were heavier than those reared in wet conditions. We also tested the correlation between eyespot size and desiccation tolerance. A negative correlation between the traits would be expected if similar developmental pathways regulate them. Consistent with this expectation, individuals with smaller eyespots had higher desiccation tolerance. Our results demonstrate plasticity in desiccation tolerance, and suggest that predator avoidance and desiccation tolerance traits may share similar developmental pathways.

Behaviour is a key yet often overlooked component of animal camouflage and how it evolves alongside colour and morphology remains poorly understood. The repeated evolution of stick-like postures in spiders offers a useful framework for investigating the importance of behaviour for concealment, since matching the environment should rely on specific body forms and postures, not just colouration. We hypothesised that when spiders behaviourally align their body with the background orientation it should influence the shape, posture and colouration that best enhances camouflage. To test this, we used a genetic algorithm and human observers to evolve digital spiders to be harder to find. We evaluated how selection under three behavioural orientation treatments (aligned, random, and evolvable orientation) influenced spider capture time, background match (lightness and colour), posture, and body (cephalothorax and abdomen) dimensions. We found that spiders that behaviourally aligned with the background took substantially longer to find through evolving a better background match, and a more elongated posture and body shape than randomly orientated spiders. Our spiders mirrored the shape and posture adopted by numerous clades, illustrating how behavioural camouflage represents a key concealment strategy in structurally complex habitats, part of an interacting suite of traits that encompass successful concealment.

O_LITerrestrial insects are vulnerable to desiccation due to their small body size. Because insects lose most water through cuticular evaporation, cuticular traits strongly influence desiccation tolerance. Individuals with greater cuticular melanisation, i.e., darker ones, are hypothesised to tolerate desiccation better than less melanised ones. C_LIO_LIIn many butterflies, pupal colour is plastic - individuals pupating on leaves tend to be greener, while those that pupate away from leaves (off-leaf), such as on tree bark or defoliated twigs, tend to be browner. Brown pupae are hypothesised to have more cuticular melanin and are expected to experience higher desiccation stress than leaf-borne green pupae. Thus, plasticity in pupal melanisation may be an adaptation against desiccation. We tested this in the butterfly Eurema blanda. C_LIO_LIWe demonstrate that individuals pupating on on-leaf substrates are greener than those pupating on off-leaf substrates, and that desiccation stress is higher in the off-leaf substrates, a microenvironment typical of brown pupae, than in typical green pupae. Using Raman spectroscopy, we show that brown, but not green, pupal cuticles contain melanin. C_LIO_LIFollowing this, we obtained greener and browner pupae by manipulating substrate colour. When subjected to desiccation stress, browner pupae survived better than greener ones. There was no correlation between pupal colour and survival in the absence of desiccation stress. Thus, melanisation appears to confer a survival advantage to pupae by increasing desiccation tolerance. C_LIO_LISurvival under desiccating conditions was inversely related to water loss. Interestingly, melanisation did not correlate with water loss, suggesting that melanisation helps tolerate desiccation through physiological mechanisms not directly related to water loss reduction. C_LIO_LIOur findings reveal an additional, crucial, adaptive value of pupal colour plasticity, a trait that has been studied primarily from an anti-predatory perspective. C_LI

Matching habitat choice provides a mechanism for individuals to maximise their expected fitness by selecting an environment that better fits their phenotype. Many animals choose their local environment by evaluating levels of perceived predation risk against possible resource gain. To test if predation risk is a major driver of habitat choice, we quantify scototaxis, or preference for dark versus light backgrounds, in juvenile guppies. As light backgrounds increase visibility to predators, this aspect of habitat choice captures variation in boldness in small fishes. By rearing and testing 586 fish descended from ten natural populations from Trinidad under common garden conditions, we first quantify (broad sense) heritable variation, i.e. evolutionary potential, within populations. Next, we test for evolutionary divergence among populations in mean preference, and if present, whether ancestral predation regime is a mediator of divergence. Finally, we ask whether families and/or populations differ in the amount of behavioural variation they contain. Habitat choice varied among families (12% of total variance), consistent with heritable variation (0.2). We also found mean preference varies among populations (11% of total variance explained). Evolutionary divergence among-populations is partly explained by ancestral predation regime, with populations from low-predation sites showing a stronger average preference for dark backgrounds than high-predation populations from the same river. Additionally, we find that within-population behavioural variation is greater in high-predation populations. We conclude that guppy populations contain heritable variation that could facilitate adaptive evolution if scototaxis is subject to natural selection. Furthermore, while genetic drift may also contribute to evolutionary divergence among-populations, observed patterns are qualitatively consistent with local adaption to predation regime. Our results suggests that high predation sites favour bolder habitat choice on average, but also that local predation regime shape the evolutionary dynamics of variation, perhaps by maintaining shy-bold variation among-individuals or by favouring individuals with less-predicable behaviour.

Mate preferences are often influenced by the magnitude of sexual signals, which are presumed to indicate underlying aspects of signaller quality. Although the perception of these signals depends on sensory processes, the role of perceptual adaptations and constraints in mate assessment is frequently overlooked. Many sensory systems follow Webers law of proportional processing, where discrimination between signals is based upon their proportional, or relative, difference rather than their absolute difference. Because preference strength varies with relative trait magnitude, Webers law could strongly influence sexual selection, changing the coevolution of traits and preferences. Here, we explore the consequences of Webers law for sexual selection using individual-based models, applying Scalar Utility Theory to mate choice. We investigate the coevolution of male ornaments and female preferences under both Fisherian and good genes scenarios, as well as scrutinizing the sexual selection of multiple ornaments and preferences. Including Webers law in these models either reduced ornament exaggeration, or promoted exaggeration and diversification of ornaments and preferences, depending on the costs of choice and how rapidly female survival decreases when preferences evolve away from the naturally selected optimum. These results highlight the importance of perception and cognitive processing in shaping sexual selection and its evolutionary impacts.

Interactions between cleaner fish Labroides dimidiatus and client fish, from which cleaners remove ectoparasites and mucus, represent a textbook example of mutualism involving sophisticated strategic decision-making. However, cleaners must also face intraspecific social challenges within a size-based hierarchy, where the largest females may eventually change sex and become males with higher reproductive rates. Following 540 individuals over 11 months, we found that, contrary to expectations, slow-growing females spent more time cleaning and cheated more frequently, without causing more negative client responses than fast-growing females did. Instead, variation in growth was best explained by social factors: fast-growing individuals experienced reduced social control, while slow growers spent more time in proximity to dominant individuals. As there was no evidence that spawning activity affected growth patterns, it appears that fast growth as a viable strategy for becoming a male largely depends on the lack of control by dominants.

Understanding how anatomical structures evolve requires disentangling the roles of integration and modularity in shaping morphological variation. The vertebral column, a serially repeated and regionally differentiated structure, provides a powerful system for investigating these processes. Here, we examine how vertebral morphology evolves in relation to whole-body elongation across the adaptive radiation of Lake Malawi cichlid fishes. We tested for evolutionary integration between the precaudal and caudal domains, as well as assessed the contributions of vertebral count, centrum shape, and intervertebral spacing on body elongation. We find strong evolutionary integration between precaudal and caudal vertebral shape, with both vertebral shapes varying along shared axes of multivariate shape change. Despite this, precaudal and caudal vertebral counts evolve independently, indicating a decoupling between the evolution of identity and morphology. Whole-body elongation is significantly associated with coordinated changes in vertebral and rib morphology, including proportional increases in centrum size, posterior displacement of neural and haemal spines, and increased rib curvature. In contrast, centrum elongation and intervertebral spacing do not independently explain body elongation beyond vertebral counts. These results demonstrate that body elongation in cichlids necessitates integrated, multivariate changes in axial morphology. Our findings highlight the importance of morphological integration in facilitating coordinated evolutionary responses in anatomical systems.

Multimodal communication plays a central role in animal behavior, particularly when individuals must integrate information from different sensory channels to make rapid decisions. In aquatic environments, chemical and visual cues differ markedly in their spatial and temporal properties, such that chemical signals may be constrained by limited spatial resolution and temporal instability, potentially requiring visual information to reliably guide social decisions. In decapod crustaceans, both cue types are known to mediate reproduction, yet their relative contribution to mate-location behavior remains unclear. Here, we tested how visual and chemical cues from males influence mate-location behavior in females of the prawn Macrobrachium rosenbergii. Females were placed in a central arena and exposed to four stimulus configurations combining visual cues (a life-size photograph of a male or a control background) and chemical cues (water from an aquarium with or without a male). Attraction was quantified as the time spent in each half of the arena. Females showed no directional preference when exposed to chemical cues alone or when visual and chemical cues were spatially incongruent. In contrast, females spent significantly more time near male-associated stimuli only when visual and chemical cues were spatially congruent. These results indicate that mate-location behavior in this species depends on multimodal integration with a strong contextual dependence on visual information, which appears to gate the effectiveness of chemical cues. Spatially congruent multimodal signals are therefore necessary to guide orientation during mate search, suggesting that disruption of visual or chemical information in aquaculture systems may impair mating efficiency.

Parasites can alter host populations in fundamentally different ways depending on whether exposure results in infection. Yet, most epidemiological and evolutionary inference focuses on established infections, leaving the fitness consequences of parasite exposure comparatively understudied. This gap is consequential because hosts are frequently exposed to diverse parasite genotypes, and these encounters can impose substantial fitness costs even when infection does not occur. Theory predicts that hosts may mitigate these costs when interacting with commonly encountered parasite genotypes, such that exposure to sympatric parasites incurs lower fitness consequences than exposure to novel, allopatric parasites. Here, we examine the fitness consequences of exposure and infection in the first intermediate host of the trophically transmitted tapeworm Schistocephalus solidus, a cyclopoid copepod that serves as the first host in a three-host life cycle. Using sympatric (Vancouver Island, Canada) and allopatric (Norway) host-parasite combinations, we found a striking reciprocal asymmetry. Sympatric parasites were significantly more infective, yet exposure to sympatric parasites imposed weaker fitness costs when infection did not establish. In contrast, allopatric parasites were less infective, but exposed females produced fewer eggs and had lower hatching success than both controls and females exposed to sympatric parasites, indicating substantial genotype-dependent costs of exposure. Moreover, we found that infection was highly virulent across all genotypes: a single parasite caused near-complete reproductive suppression and reduced host survival across all host-parasite pairings, confirming S. solidus as a castrating parasite in copepods. Together, these results demonstrate that exposure, not just infection, acts as a critical ecological filter with potentially large and underappreciated consequences for host population dynamics and parasite transmission.

The evolution of alternative male reproductive strategies represents an intriguing evolutionary phenomenon. Divergent strategies are persistently at risk of local extinction or invasion, depending on the suites of traits expressed within and between morphs; hence, understanding the correlational selection that aligns reproductive strategies with behaviour, morphology and physiology is key to understanding the origin and maintenance of genetic polymorphisms. In the polychromatic painted dragon, Ctenophorus pictus, yellow, orange and red morphs are well characterised, but the blue morph has been historically absent from studied populations. Here we document the local distribution, morphology and male-contest interactions in a population where blue males are relatively common. We find that blue males express head colouration after a reaching a threshold body size, and that small blue males can reside in close proximity to other males; patterns consistent with a novel size-dependent conditional tactic within the suite of genetic strategies seen in this species. Condition-dependent, positively allometric throat bibs were non-randomly distributed among male morphs, implicating variation in correlational selection and the genetic architecture of the polymorphism. We were unable to definitively assign a morph that was superior in male competition but found that within morphs, male size was the determinant of competitive success, whilst between morphs it was not. Furthermore, contests between morphs were resolved with less aggression than contests within morphs, supporting the idea that badges resolve conflict, and that the invasion of new colour morphs may be facilitated by negative frequency dependent benefits to novel colour variants. These findings highlight the divergent phenotypic, genetic and selective environments that lead to the diversity of colour morphs.

The diversity of body shapes is one of the most prominent features of phenotypic variation in mammals. Yet, mammalian body shapes are poorly quantified and the underlying components contributing to its diversity as well as its relationship to other components of the skeleton are rarely tested. Here, we use lagomorphs (hares, rabbits and pikas) as a model system to (1) investigate which components of the skeleton contributed the most to body shape diversity, (2) examine the relationships between body shape and relative limb lengths, and (3) test how body size, ecotype, burrowing behavior, and locomotor mode influenced variation in lagomorph body shape and appendicular morphology. We quantified the body shape and functional proxies of the appendicular skeleton in 40 lagomorph species from osteological specimens held at museum collections. Using phylogenetic comparative methods, we found the relative length of the ribs and elongation or shortening of the thoracic and lumbar regions contributed the most to body shape evolution across lagomorphs. Second, we found that only leporids (hares and rabbits) exhibited a significant relationship between limb length and body shape, where more elongate species exhibit relatively shorter forelimbs and hindlimbs. Lastly, we found that models incorporating body size were the best predictors of lagomorph body shape and the majority of the appendicular traits, whereas models incorporating burrowing behavior and locomotor mode were largely poor fits. Broadly, these results indicate that larger lagomorphs tend to exhibit more robust body shapes with longer, more gracile forelimbs, whereas smaller lagomorphs tend to exhibit more elongate body shapes with shorter, more robust forelimbs. Overall, this work contributes to the growing understanding of mammalian body shape evolution and demonstrates the importance of not omitting body size in ecomorphological analyses.

The mechanisms driving host-symbiont associations across space and time in contemporary mutualisms can give insight into the capacity for symbiotic organisms to respond to environmental change. High specificity between partners can increase cooperation and facilitate efficient holobiont selection, whereas low specificity could reduce host benefit, but facilitate adaptive associations across heterogeneous environments. The present study explores specificity in natural populations of a cnidarian-algal model, Exaiptasia diaphana, across a latitudinal gradient to understand the genetic and environmental effects driving host-symbiont associations, and their relation to heritable and/or environmental symbiont acquisition. We found that symbiotic associations were extremely flexible in E. diaphana, regardless of transmission mode. E. diaphana were capable of associating with diverse symbiont communities across genetically identical hosts seeded with vertically transmitted symbionts, as well as across highly connected host populations which acquire symbionts horizontally. Host population connectivity was complex and unrelated to geographic distance, whereas symbiont community composition tracked the thermal gradient, potentially due to context dependent biotic interactions. These results indicate that in a flexible symbiosis, symbiont communities are environmentally-determined, suggesting the future of this symbiosis will likely depend on climate adaptation of symbionts.

Within species, individuals of the same age can differ in size. Previously, parental genetics, nutrition, space, and social interactions have been suggested to explain different growth rates. However, direct effects of larger individuals on the physiology and growth of smaller individuals are poorly understood. In this study, we investigated how larger individuals of the marine worm Platynereis dumerilii can impact the growth of smaller conspecifics. Comparing growth distributions in communally and individually reared worms, we show that larger worms suppress the growth of smaller ones. Furthermore, we were able to demonstrate that this suppression is chemically mediated. The chemical cue does not originate from faeces but is water soluble, stable for several days and smaller than 3 kDa. Our findings highlight the importance of non-reproduction related chemical signalling, showing evidence that dominant individuals can chemically suppress the growth of their conspecifics. This study provides new insights into how hierarchy can be established and maintained in a population and is particularly relevant for the growing community studying this model species.

Dormancy is a widespread adaptive strategy that allows organisms to survive in temporally varying habitats by suspending development and reproduction. Although environmental variability is expected to shape dormancy strategies, it remains unclear how differences in environmental variability and predictability influence both the production of dormant embryos and the termination of dormancy. We addressed these questions by comparing D. pulex and D. obtusa, two closely related species that inhabit environments differing in variability and predictability. We hypothesized that D. obtusa, which inhabits ephemeral environments, would exhibit a greater propensity for sexual reproduction and dormancy and would require stronger cues to break dormancy than D. pulex, which occurs in more permanent, predictable habitats. Consistent with our hypothesis, D. obtusa lineages produced significantly more males and ephippia than D. pulex when reared under identical laboratory conditions, indicating greater investment in sexual reproduction and dormancy. Contrary to our hypothesis, we found no difference in responsiveness to cues between the two species. Across species, embryos broke dormancy and hatched most readily after experiencing changes in cold and light, even if not experienced at the same time. In contrast, desiccation reduced the propensity to break dormancy. Together, these results indicate that species occupying more ephemeral environments invest more heavily in the production of dormant offspring, but that the environmental cues regulating dormancy termination appear broadly similar between species. This pattern suggests that while investment in dormancy may evolve in response to environmental variability, the mechanisms controlling dormancy termination are more conserved.

Existing theory examining the coevolutionary dynamics of species range borders assumes random dispersal, which causes maladaptive gene flow from the range core to the range margins and contributes to the formation of range limits. However, dispersal is unlikely to be random for many organisms in nature, calling into question existing theoretical predictions. For example, if individuals exhibit phenotype-dependent adaptive dispersal strategies such as matching habitat choice, then the resulting adaptive gene flow toward species range margins could facilitate range expansions and potentially prevent the formation of range limits by interspecific competition. To test this idea, we use a comprehensive mathematical model to develop a quantitative theory of range border coevolution that incorporates phenotype-optimal dispersal--a particular form of matching habitat choice in which individuals follow the gradient in an environmental optimum phenotype to settle in the habit best suited for their phenotype. We find that instead of preventing competitively formed range limits, adaptive dispersal leads to sharper range limits and reduced character displacement in sympatry. These differences are particularly remarkable when natural selection is weak, when individuals are specialized in their resource use, or when individuals are highly sensitive to environmental conditions. We show that matching habitat choice causes backward edge-to-core movements which dynamically interact with the effects of interspecific competition to establish the range limits. Thus, the formation of range limits by interspecific competition is robust to assumptions about individual dispersal. Further, our results identify the competitive advantage of evolving matching habitat choice in steep environmental gradients, especially for slowly-growing species in rapidly fluctuating climates.

Many mobile animals move to locate and consume resources, making energy gain and growth dependent on activity. Yet the role of activity in shaping predator-prey interactions in food webs has not been broadly considered. Here, we synthesize empirical examples to examine how three activity traits (mean, variance, and timing) vary among taxa (fish, mammals, birds) and between predators and prey across temporal scales. We then use predator-prey models to explore how these diverse activity patterns influence stability. Motivated by emerging activity patterns, our theory shows that fluctuating activity rates can drive predator-prey interaction strengths with major consequences for stability. Future research is needed on activity trait patterning, links between activity and attack rates, and the consequences of activity for predator-prey interactions to whole food webs. This is especially critical as human-driven changes to abiotic cues increasingly alter animal activity rates and may rewire food webs.

A hosts diet can alter the course of parasite infection. This is especially true of trophic parasites, which a host acquires through feeding. While a large body of work attests to the role of diet in the spread of disease within-hosts, diet can also impact host density and encounter rate with parasites, both of which are expected to modify disease dynamics. When parasites are acquired through feeding, epidemics may be larger and more severe on high-quality diets if these diets support a higher density of hosts that feed more and thus ingest more parasites. Alternately, epidemics may be more severe on low-quality diets if malnourishment decreases hosts ability to resist disease. To differentiate these hypothesized effects of diet on disease, we quantified individual infections and epidemic dynamics for the natural microsporidian parasite Nematocida ironsii infecting its nematode host Caenorhabditis elegans. We measured feeding rate, parasite transmission, and host fitness across three bacterial diets that vary in quality and elicit distinct feeding behaviors in C. elegans. We found that low-quality diets reduced feeding rate, which corresponded to reduced acquisition of parasite spores. However, these diet-mediated differences in parasite acquisition did not directly map onto fitness consequences: hosts eating the poor-quality diet had similar reductions in fitness to those on higher quality diets. During epidemics, a combination of increased parasite acquisition and higher population growth rates resulted in higher parasite abundance for hosts on high-quality diets. Our work underscores the importance of considering both individual- and population-level impacts acting in concert to determine how diet affects the spread of infectious disease.

Arthropods exhibit an exceptional diversity of life histories, where developmental modes involve moulting stage progressions with changes ranging from the bare minimal to the dramatically transformative. While this variability drives many research questions aiming to understand evolutionary and developmental underpinnings of life history differences, it can complicate comparative analyses across taxa. However, this can be approached by applying a framework that defines metamorphosis as a post-embryonic stage progression characterised by substantial changes in morphology and adaptive landscape. Employing this framework with a phylogenomic dataset spanning 26 orders and encompassing four independently arising metamorphic lineages, we explore gene repertoire evolutionary dynamics potentially associated with metamorphosis in Pancrustacea. The approach contrasts gene family evolutionary dynamics inferred to have occurred in the last common ancestors of the metamorphic Insecta, Copepoda, Eucarida, and Thecostraca, with those of their sister lineages, as well as of descendent and ancestral nodes. The results reveal that the metamorphosis ancestors are characterised by an elevated number of gene family births and expansions. Expanded gene families share a set of commonly enriched biological processes across all metamorphosis ancestors, suggesting functional convergence by independent evolution of distinct gene families involved in embryonic and post-embryonic development and nervous system differentiation. Evolutionary modelling further highlights a subset of these families exhibiting signatures of adaptive, lineage-specific gene family size increases associated with metamorphic development. These families include genes implicated in neural and sensory development, segmentation, and moulting. These findings support a model of the evolution of pancrustacean metamorphosis where distinct gene families from a common functional toolkit expand and are co-opted into facilitating transitions to multi-phasic life cycles. This reframes the role of moulting in arthropod diversification to be recognised as an important reservoir of genetic change that can potentiate truly remarkable life history transitions.

Elucidating how habitat degradation facilitates extinction is critical for effective conservation efforts. Here, we propose integrating physiologically-structured population models into stochastic population viability analyses to assess how differing consequences of habitat degradation interact to drive extinction dynamics in a focal population. Using the isolated spectacled caiman Caiman crocodilus population/ecomorph from the Apaporis River as a case study, we find that threatening the resource base, which individuals increasingly rely upon, to outgrow vulnerable size ranges and mature accelerates extinction. We also found that when habitat degradation impacts both the primary adult and juvenile resource bases, this can have marked synergistic effects on threatening population viability. By contrast, destroying nesting sites has only a small effect on accelerating the impact of deteriorating prey availability. Through integrating community-level feedback between habitat degradation/change and population dynamics/structure, our approach provides a comparative framework for assessing the relative importance of distinct mechanisms through which habitat degradation ultimately drives extinction risk.

The Red Queen Hypothesis proposes that genetic variation is maintained in populations through antagonistic coevolution of hosts and parasites. A major assumption of the Red Queen Hypothesis is tight genetic specificity for infection. However, it has been argued that this genetic interaction of host and parasite (GHxGP) is sensitive to environmental context (GHxGPxE). Environmental change could accordingly disrupt coevolutionary oscillations on relevant time scales, calling into question antagonistic coevolution as a general and robust explanation for the maintenance of genetic diversity. To evaluate this critique, we used the plant-parasitic nematode Meloidogyne arenaria and its natural bacterial parasite Pasteuria penetrans to determine if specificity is altered by temperature. We exposed six isofemale host lines to five parasite sources at three ecologically relevant temperatures. We found that, at two of three temperatures, susceptibility to infection depended on the specific combination of host line and parasite source (GHxGP). This specificity varied across temperatures, consistent with a GHxGPxE effect. This three-way interaction was driven both by quantitative changes in the strength of specificity across temperatures and shifts in the susceptibility rankings of host-parasite combinations. Our study contributes a rare experimental test of a proposed challenge to the Red Queen Hypothesis and suggests the potential for environmental context to change host-parasite specificity.